Last week I wrote about my Nana's faith, and today I'm writing about my much more enigmatic paternal grandfather, Earl. This is an excerpt from my manuscript that will likely be cut if it ever sees the publishing light of day, so I figured I'd use it on the blog (especially since I'm out of town and writing all this week's posts in advance!).
Papa cooked, laundered, vacuumed, dusted, baked bubbling, tart apple pies with flakey crust that melted on your tongue and doted, absolutely doted on Nana, whom he adoringly called Peanut, on account of her tiny stature. He waited on her day and night – hot tea with lots of milk and toast for breakfast; heart pills at 10 a.m. on the dot; her favorite green-foil wrapped Andes mints for a late afternoon treat. Nana even kept a bell on her bedside table – they slept in separate bedrooms – to summon Papa during the night if she needed a pill or a neck rub. In his own unique, untraditional way, Papa wore his heart on his sleeve.
Yet in so many ways my grandfather was a mystery.
I can’t say for sure, because I really don’t have any idea what my grandfather believed in his heart, but I suspect his was a tenuous faith at best. He tolerated Nana’s insistence that we choose our knickknacks as part of their bequest, he attended church every Saturday evening, he took communion, but did he believe? I’m not really sure.
I never heard Papa mention God in any context, ever. This is not surprising in and of itself, given that he was not a verbally demonstrative man. But I remember glancing at him covertly when we were at Mass and noticing that he never uttered a prayer. He didn’t even move his lips, nor do I ever recall him making the sign of the cross. Was he reciting the prayers in his head? Was he praying at all? Who knew? His face was an indecipherable mask.
Not only were his emotions rigidly controlled, as a survivor of the Great Depression, my grandfather learned to control his environment, too, to offset his fear of failure, his fear of losing everything. Just like he oversaw the domestic duties of his home and kept it all running like a well-oiled machine, he ensured his survival by methodically accumulating wealth and hording money. So many of my grandfather’s actions suggested a refusal to relinquish control to anyone, God included, and as he aged the tendency grew increasingly worse. When he was forced to move into a nursing home after his stroke, he refused to sign over the deed to his house to his only son, terrified that my father would steal his assets and leave him penniless and dependent. Instead, the home my grandfather built by hand was turned over to the state, where it remained until my grandmother died, nearly a decade after my grandfather’s death.
As Papa languished in the nursing home after his stroke, he seemed to withdraw further and further into himself. It could have been depression – always a proud, independent, stubborn man, Papa’s body had betrayed him and relegated him to a nursing home bed – but it seemed a deeper, more profound despair. While his mind remained as sharp as ever, he grew more and more bitter, barely able to force a cordial greeting when I visited and obviously wishing that I, and all others who entered his room, would just disappear. Nothing seemed to bring him comfort, not his favorite molasses cookies that Brad baked for him every week, not his grandchildren, his son or his Peanut, not the weekly visits from his parish priest and deacon. I witnessed nothing that brought him solace in the last years of his life; everyone and everything seemed an almost intolerable burden.
When I think of Papa lying withered and incapacitated in his nursing home bed, the word fear is what first springs to my mind. Maybe it was the way he tenaciously clung to life in the years following his stroke; he seemed to endure rather than actually live, to hang on with an iron grip of desperation and resolute determination. It was like he knew he could not defeat the inevitable, but yet didn’t have any other option but to try. Maybe he was praying; maybe inside his own head, unbeknownst to us all, he was pleading with God to end his anguish, to give him peace, to bring him eternal life. But something about him, something about the way Papa lay in bed and stared at the ceiling, his face an impenetrable, stony mask, told me he was not.
During my many non-believing years, my grandfather's retreat into himself terrified me. I think I saw myself, decades from now, in him. Is this how a non-believer ends up, I wondered? Is this it? Is this is what's coming to me, too? The thought filled me with horror. Yet it wasn't enough to compel me to believe in God. I resigned myself to my fate and tried to think about it as little as possible.
I wish now that I'd asked him. He may not have told the truth, but still, I wish I had asked my grandfather about his faith, what he believed, if he believed. It never crossed my mind to broach that conversation, but I wish now that I had tried. At the very least, it may have shed some light on the enigmatic man that was my grandfather.
Read more...